Kombo : : : PS3 | 360 | Wii | Cube | Xbox | PSP | DS | Forums | Podcasts

AROUND KOMBO:
BLOG
My Xbox is Sexy
Kill Screen #7
Major League Baseball 2K9
Console
Xbox 360
Publisher
2K Games
Genre
Sports
Developer
Visual Concepts
Release Date
03/03/09
ESRB Rating
Everyone
StumbleUpon Toolbar  
REVIEW
Major League Baseball 2K9
March 15, 2009 | 3:42 PM PST

by: Matt Furtado

Kombo's Review Policy: Our reviews are written for you. Our goal is to write honest, to-the-point reviews that don't waste your time. This is why we've split our reviews into four sections: What the Game's About, What's Hot, What's Not and Final Word, so that you can easily find the information you want from our reviews.



What the Game's About
The weather is beginning to warm up and the crisp feeling of spring is in the air. Is there a better time of year than spring? The best part of spring is that baseball season is once again ready to start off. Old rivalries like the Red Sox vs Yankees are about to be born anew. The historical Yankee Stadium will no longer be witnessed this year, and a new era will begin down the road at the new Yankee Stadium. To commemorate the new 2009 baseball season, we have MLB 2K9.

What's Hot
When you put the game into your system, you'll be glad to know the game will actually start up. You'll see a title screen and all the nice little options we have come to expect out of our sport titles. You can play Season, Homerun Derby, Exhibition, and even hop online and play against some friends or whoever else happens to be playing. The online mode works very well.

2K made a major improvement in the visuals for the stadiums. The stadiums have a lot more vibrant colors and it really gives off the sense of being in the stadium during a crisp spring or summer day enjoying a game of baseball. The character animations have also been reworked and have a more fluid motion to them. No longer do pitchers look like jerky messes when delivering a pitch. Turning a double-play looks as smooth as butter and that's what baseball is all about.

What's Not
Just about everything else about the game isn't hot. The game is a complete mess. It has glitches, bugs, and so many problems with it that it's unplayable. Have you ever watched, or, hell, even played a baseball game where the player runs through the wall and makes a catch in the grandstands? Well, I sure have in MLB 2K9. My players have actually fallen through the ground while running to first base and never came back up and as a result, got thrown out on a ball hit off the wall. I guess you call that an unlucky break. If only the ball had gone over the fence, maybe the game would have locked up because my player would have never rounded the bases. Then again, maybe the opposing player would have just fused with wall and caught the ball, too.

To make matters even more humorous, you'll be able to throw out anyone at second base during a pick off throw. For some reason, once the player gets to second base, they forget that the pitcher can throw back. It's guaranteed to work 100% of the time. You are probably thinking to yourself that these kinds of bugs and problems only come around once in a while. Wrong. They are frequent. Falling baseballs will hit outfielders in the back of the head when they ricochet off the wall, and then the player won't pick the ball up and randomly just roll around the outfield grass. It's like watching a group of diseased Neanderthals playing the game for the first time.



There are a lot more problems I could share with you, but I don't want to waste your time naming all of them. While the stadiums and character animations are fluid and vibrant, the facial features of the characters are not.

Final Word
Want to play baseball this year? Buy a glove and ball and play with your friends. Even if you have no athletic ability in your genes, you'll have more fun playing it for real. If you have a PS3, buy MLB: 09 The Show. Just don't buy, rent, or play this game unless you want a good laugh. 2K needs to give this game some steroids, because it needs an edge on the competition.
Visuals
Fluid character animations and sharp stadium scene. Faces are distorted and look terrible, though.
7.0
Sound
Recycled soundtrack from NBA 2K9. Announcers are what you expect from a baseball game. Nothing too impressive, though.
5.0
Control
This the game does somewhat well. Too bad the characters don't do what they are told most of the time.
7.0
Gameplay
If you manage to get by all the bugs, you'll be offered a lot in season mode, exhibition, and the other options the game offers. But, the bugs and glitches will plague your experience for most of it.
5.0
Lasting Appeal
I'd give this a 10 if you just want a good laugh. But don't play this game.
2.0
Verdict
Horrible baseball game. Too many bugs and glitches to even consider it a finished product. How does a game like this ship?
4.5
[not an average]
Review Scores Guide

Got something that we should post on the site? Send it to us!
February 8, 2010
Twenty more winners to go for our Game a Day Giveaway! Don't hesitate... enter today! Also, make sure you become a fan of Kombo on Facebook!!!

-- Ken Cauley, Editor in Chief

Kombo Breaker
FTW
Kombo's Game a Day Giveaway!
We're giving away a new game EVERYDAY throughout all of February!

Official Contest Page!

WINNERS:

  • February 2: John Riemer, Virgina
  • February 3: Jonathan Dowell, Pennsylvania
  • February 4: Chris Ryan, Florida
  • February 5: Chris Foster, Michigan
  • February 6: Adam Cuevas, Florida
  • February 7: Josh Minar, Kentucky
  • February 8: Bradley Mosbacher, Missouri
  • If SEGA made Shenmue 3, would it SELL?
    Vote!
    (02/09/10 | 5:56 AM PST)
    HDTV vs. SNES
    (02/08/10 | 12:03 PM PST)
    Console Wars "A Bit Silly," Says 2K Marin
    DiRT 2!!!
  • DiRT 2 for Xbox 360 or PlayStation 3
    Enter to win!
    E-mail us and include your full name, age and mailing address to enter.

  • Software
    Hardware
    All Time
    Weekly
    9.89m Japan
    31.48m America
    25.90m Others
    67.28M 
    1.25m Japan
    21.76m America
    14.63m Others
    37.64M 
    4.74m Japan
    12.71m America
    14.31m Others
    31.76M 
    29.79m Japan
    44.83m America
    50.20m Others
    124.81M 
    14.02m Japan
    18.98m America
    20.85m Others
    53.85M